PROVIDENCE — Speakers at a presentation and panel on antisemitism and hate Nov. 17 at the Bonnie & Donald Dwares Jewish Community Center discussed the state of hate in Rhode Island and emphasized that it was still possible to build partnerships with people outside of the Jewish community to fight it.
The event, entitled “Confronting Antisemitism in Rhode Island,” was sponsored by the Jewish Alliance of Greater Rhode Island, the New England region of the Anti-Defamation League and the Sandra Bornstein Holocaust Education Center and drew about 100 people. The program consisted of a presentation on hate crimes by Taylor Dumpson, a special assistant attorney general with the Rhode Island Attorney General’s Civil Rights Unit and then a panel discussion on antisemitism.
The panel featured Anti-Defamation League New England Regional Director Samantha Joseph, Sandra Bornstein Holocaust Education Center Executive Director Wendy Joering and Alliance Chief Strategy Officer Stephanie Hague, moderated by Alliance Director of Community Advocacy and Engagement Emily Gaudreau.
Joseph said, “Voices of allies are even more important than Jewish voices in the fight against antisemitism, because Jews are not trusted as narrators of our own oppression. That is literally what the research says,” referring to studies carried out by ADL’s Center for Antisemitism Research.
“If you're Jewish,” Joseph continued, “making sure that you have a non-Jewish voice at your events and encouraging allyship is just really important.”
Dumpson’s presentation focused on hate crimes and bias incidents — and her own experiences as a hate crimes survivor.
Dumpson was the first Black woman to serve as student government president at American University. On her first day in office, a masked perpetrator hung bananas from nooses on campus, putting them in front of her student government building and the bus stops near her dorm.
As a Black woman who experienced hate based on who she is, Dumpson explained, she can understand how many Jews are feeling.
“This is actually part of why I went to Yeshiva [University] for law school,” Dumpson said. “I recognized that as a Black woman who's navigating life and trying to figure out what a new normal is in the 21st century, navigating threats from Nazis, where else did I want to be going to school than with a community that understood the fear that I had.”
While building alliances, Hague said during the panel, people also need to fight against antisemitism coming from within their own ranks. “We have to be willing to recognize and talk about antisemitism no matter where we see it,” she said. Hague added that doing so can be harder than critiquing antisemitism from opposing political camps, but that it is “even more important to call that out.”
The ADL’s 2025 Audit of Antisemitic Incidents found that across the country and Rhode Island, incidents had decreased from 2024 — but were still far above the relatively stable baseline before the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack in Israel.
Steven A. Baker, president and CEO of the Alliance, noted in his welcoming remarks that he only recently moved to the state but has already seen antisemitic activity, especially centered around the mayoral race. Incumbent Mayor Brett Smiley is Jewish, and antisemitic sentiment was directed at him, including swastikas drawn on his campaign signs.
“I just know from talking to so many of you and talking to so many community members…that they have felt unsafe and they have felt that there is a rise [in antisemitism], that the climate around here is not what it used to be,” Baker said. “It makes all of us kind of question a little bit and look around a little bit more.”
Hague said, “We just looked at the data this morning. Actually, we're really neck-and-neck on where we were last year.” She added that 53 incidents had been reported to the Alliance this year, similar to the number at this time last year.
The ADL’s number for 2025 was 26 in Rhode Island. ADL’s number was lower for two reasons. First, incidents in southeastern Massachusetts are often reported to the Alliance. ADL tracks Massachusetts data separately. Second, the Alliance takes raw data and sends it to ADL, which maintains a rigorous process of investigation to ensure that only incidents meeting ADL’s criteria are included.
Hague and Joseph emphasized that the actual number of antisemitic incidents was likely much higher, because many incidents go unreported, for a variety of reasons, including “fatigue” within the Jewish community around the issue.
Joseph explained the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of antisemitism, which ADL uses. She focused on IHRA’s most controversial part, how criticism of Israel can become antisemitic. “General criticism of Israeli policy is not antisemitism; we don't include it in our audit of antisemitic incidents,” she said. “But when you are denying Israel's right to exist, portraying Israel as uniquely evil amongst all the countries in the world or holding it to a double standard that you're not holding other countries accountable for, that is where we see it cross the line.”
As an example, Joseph said that saying “Free Palestine” is not antisemitism. “But when somebody writes it on a brick and throws it through the window of our kosher supermarket,” it is.
ADL’s Audit of Antisemitic Incidents in 2024, the height of the demonstrations against Israel’s war against Hamas, tracked about 5,000 rallies against Israeli policy. It found that expressions of antisemitism took place at roughly half of them.
The panel’s speakers echoed Dumpson’s comments about antisemitism’s intersection with other forms of hatred. Joering described antisemitism as a conspiracy theory that is often tied to other forms of hate. She pointed to crimes targeting Black, Muslim and LGBTQ communities, saying that often antisemitism can act as “kind of the narrative glue that holds some of this hate together.” Earlier in the evening, Drumpson made a similar point, showing a picture of a house belonging to African Americans vandalized with a swastika and anti-Black slurs.
Asked if there was anything to be cheerful about, Joering and others pointed to partnerships the Jewish Alliance has built with school districts, police departments, Christian groups and others across the state. For example, following a 2017 bomb threat at the JCC, Joering, then the Alliance’s security liaison, coordinated response efforts across communal lines and with local, state and national law enforcement.
Antisemitic incidents can be reported to the Jewish Alliance via its website. The Alliance tracks that data and reports it to law enforcement and ADL, which tracks incidents nationally.